New research from the University of Oxford indicates that extending current restrictions on foods high in fat, salt and sugar (HFSS) to include the updated Nutrient Profiling Model (NPM18) could increase the number of products affected by almost 25%, according to the Institute of Grocery Distribution (IGD).
The study was supported by the National Institute of Health and Care Research (NIHR), with the research questions developed jointly with the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities (OHID). The analysis was carried out independently by the University of Oxford.
Updated model could bring more products within HFSS rules
Researchers reviewed 15,514 products spanning 13 categories currently covered by HFSS legislation. Product data was collected from the websites of Tesco, Sainsbury’s, Asda and Ocado, including M&S products.
Using the 2018 Nutrient Profiling Model, 72% of the products were identified as high in fat, salt or sugar. This compares with 58% under the existing NPM 2004/05 framework.
Overall, 84% of the products received the same result under both nutrient profiling systems. However, among the 16% whose status changed, 93% moved from a pass under NPM 2004/05 to a fail under NPM 2018.
Breakfast cereal and yogurt categories face significant impact
Breakfast cereals and yogurts were among the food categories most affected by the proposed model. The proportion of breakfast cereals passing the assessment dropped from 79% to 39%, while the yogurt pass rate declined from 78% to 36%.
Ice cream and desserts also recorded fewer products passing the assessment. By contrast, there was limited change for confectionery, cakes and biscuits, as most items in these categories already failed under the current model. IGD identified the switch from total sugars to free sugars, together with stricter scoring thresholds, as the principal reasons for the changes.
The Government consultation on extending NPM 2018 to existing advertising and promotions rules closed on 17th June. However, the official response and final policy decisions have yet to be published. IGD said the effect of NPM 2018 on food and beverage businesses will “depend heavily” on the composition of their product portfolios.

